The Five Biggest Irish Whiskey Myths

Irish whiskey couldn’t really be any more popular. During the last decade, the category has just exploded. According to the Distilled Spirits Council of the United States, sales increased by 17.5 percent in 2013 alone—and that’s after rising nearly 400 percent between 2002 and 2012.

But unfortunately, we still often hear a lot of falsehoods about the spirit from both drinkers and bartenders. So to help dispel five of the biggest myths, we enlisted Jack McGarry from New York’s acclaimed The Dead Rabbit. He’s not only from Ireland but also definitely knows his stuff—after all, he was named International Bartender of the Year at last July’s Tales of the Cocktail conference. So keep his advice in mind as you gear up for St. Patrick’s Day. Sláinte!

Jameson is Catholic and Bushmills is Protestant.

This is one of the myths we encounter all the time, since Bushmills is located in predominantly Protestant Northern Ireland, and Jameson is produced in the heavily Catholic Republic of Ireland. But “this couldn’t be any further from the truth,” McGarry says. For one, because there are only a few distilleries on the whole island, they trade casks. So your Bushmills may contain some Jameson-made whiskey. That’s not to mention that the current master distiller at Bushmills, Colum Egan, is Catholic, and that John Jameson, founder of his eponymous brand, was likely Protestant—and Scottish, for that matter.

Scotch is better than Irish whiskey.

McGarry hears this one a lot from Scottish bartenders. While there is, of course, no right answer, there are a few points to consider if you decide to take a side. Scotch has had an advantage, in that the selection of single malts and blends available in America dwarfs the number of Irish whiskies. (This also reflects the fact that there are nearly 100 distilleries in Scotland compared to just a handful in Ireland.) But that’s definitely changing, with a range of interesting Irish whiskies like Green Spot becoming available in the US for the first time, and other new brands launching and/or building their own distilleries.

Another argument for Scotch supremacy is that it’s generally distilled twice, while Irish whiskey is usually distilled three times. “Some people say that three distillations makes the whiskey taste too light, but I wholeheartedly disagree with that,” McGarry says. “What I love about Irish whiskey is how approachable and versatile it is.”

Irish whiskey is only good for shots.

Yes, plenty of Irish whiskey is ordered as shots or in Pickle Backs, but it also works in a number of cocktails, including, of course, McGarry’s The Dead Rabbit Irish Coffee. Plus, many of the whiskies can be sipped neat or on the rocks. “We have a multitude of avenues in which it can be enjoyed, and let’s not forget: Life is all about variety,” McGarry says.

The popularity of Irish whiskey is new.

While the popularity of Irish whiskey is exploding lately, the first boom for the country’s distillers was more than a century ago. At the time, the US was flooded with Irish whiskey from the more than 100 distilleries on the Emerald Isle. “It was the biggest whiskey in America at its peak,” McGarry says. But thanks to a number of factors, including trade wars with Britain, Prohibition in the States and two World Wars, the industry was decimated. Fortunately, thing have changed over the last 20 years. “It’s back now, and it’s back to stay!”

All Irish whiskies taste the same.

We’ll chalk this one up to Jameson’s domination of the US market, but you can now find a large range of Irish whiskies that feature very different flavor profiles. For example, “we are seeing the resurgence of the classic Irish pot still style of whiskey,” notes McGarry, including Redbreast, Green Spot and Powers. There are also Irish single malts like Knappogue Castle and Tyrconnell, which both offer  whiskies that have been finished in sherry or other wine casks. And there’s even the peated Connemara. “So you can clearly see how diverse the Irish whiskey world is,” McGarry says. “The juice speaks for itself.”

Try these delicious St. Patrick’s Day cocktails, and let us know in the comments below if you’ve heard any other myths about Irish whiskey.

Locations: Ireland
Series & Type: Products Trends
Appears in 1 Collection

From our Friends



  • saoirse4us.a4697a posted 1 month ago

    No such thing as "Bad" Irish whiskey......Only good and better...As to the comment ..looks as if someone else has the same good opinions that I do.

  • saoirse4us.a4697a posted 1 month ago

    No such thing as "Bad" Irish whiskey......Only good and better...

  • blank.sst.17c58 posted 7 months ago

    I spent some time in southern Ireland with my dad. We ordered some bushmills and a local sitting next to us told us that bushmills "has only hired 4 catholics, and 2 of them had to lie about it." I know he was joking, but the sentiment was clear

  • travelmpq.8caf2d6 posted 12 months ago

    I agree with Bil Marsano. My father was an IRA member during the War of Independence. He came to America after the IRA was defeated in the Irish Civil War. He always said that Bushmills was "Orange Whiskey" because it was produced in Northern Ireland. He drank Jameson and Paddy's because they were produced in the Republic. The religion of their founders had nothing to do with it.

  • fearraigh posted 4 years ago

    'Ancient prejudices'? These prejudices were born in the US, not in Ireland. Bushmills has NEVER been identified, much less scorned, as a 'Protestant' whiskey in Ireland, even at the height of the Troubles. The company even faced the threat of a boycott in the 1990s from the Protestant Democratic Unionist Party for sponsoring the Antrim GAA team (a sport played largely by Catholics). How come Bushmills and Black Bush are available in every bar in the mainy Catholic 26 counties? Similarly, John Jameson was Protestant and one of the biggest Unionists going at a time when Ireland rose up against British rule in a non-sectarian uprising. In any case, both distilleries have been French-owned, by Pernod-Ricard, since 1988. Irish-Americans are long viewed in the old country as knowing Sweet FA about the politics or history of Ireland. They are welcome to their barstool theories, Belfast Car Bombs and 'ancient prejudices'. Just stop trying to pretend they have any relevance to what actually goes on in Ireland.

  • ellesmith.fagan.5 posted 4 years ago

    Setting up a new house, updating my liquor knowledge for Saint Patrick's Day coming. Thank you for this fine article ....
    one comment - can ye smile from it? perhaps not. When I was a girl in a family where 7 Irish Uncles would tip a few to their Saint Patrick's Day - born Da, till he was 90 and ready to go on: it was the consensus that the Irish Whiskey went down in popularity for fairness' sake. Till they win their full freedom, they are NOT entitled to their cups, since one gets ones treats AFTER the chores are done. :-D
    When all 4 green fields bloom once again, we can go to get wild mountain thyme.

  • stinkoid posted 4 years ago

    My spouse's parents lived across the street from the Midleton distillery since the mid-60s. It's been interesting over the years to see the scale of the enterprise increase many-fold over the decades. The warehouses used for ageing are now ginourmous.

    Last time I did it, the distillery tour was worth the effort, particularly if you paired it with the optional tasting.

  • Coopster posted 4 years ago

    Does it really matter CATHOLIC-PROTESTANT? No. like McGarry says " The juice speaks for itself"

  • posted 4 years ago

    Re "JAMESON IS CATHOLIC AND BUSHMILLS IS PROTESTANT": McGarry's points may have some validity, but we're not talking about technicalities here, we're talking about ancient prejudices. And so long as the two whiskeys are produced in their current locations, Jameson will be Catholic and Bushmills Protestant to people who hold or respect the specific prejudices involved. This would be true even were both whiskeys to be absolutely identical in every way. People don't let go of these things, and so long as they don't lead to bloodshed, they're acceptable as historical expressions and references.

~ all comments loaded ~
Next Article
Are you smarter than
your bartender?

Think you know the booze?
Let’s start with some basics.